【禁闻】法遭遇恐怖袭击 中西态度大不同

【新唐人2015年01月12日讯】1月7号,圣诞节和新年的节日气氛还没有散尽,一场突如其来的事件将法国人的喜庆彻底打碎。位于巴黎的法国著名讽刺画报《查理周刊》(Charlie Hebdo),遭到伊斯兰恐怖份子袭击,多人遇难。这起事件在法国引起了如同“911”恐怖袭击一样的震动。11号,包括欧美40多个国家的首脑在内的100多万人,在巴黎举行游行集会,悼念遇难者,并展示全球反对恐怖主义的决心。不过,中共对这起事件的态度,却与国际社会大不相同。请看报导。

针对《查理周刊》的恐怖袭击和警方随后对恐怖份子的追剿过程,总共造成包括3名警察在内的17人死亡,20多人受伤,3名恐怖份子被打死。这也是法国半个多世纪以来,遭遇的最惨重的袭击。

法国总统奥朗德于7号晚发表电视讲话,呼吁法国人民团结,捍卫共和原则和宽容精神,并重申绝不向极端势力妥协。奥朗德还宣布法国将降半旗三天进行哀悼。

美国、英国、德国等多国领导人纷纷谴责这起恐怖袭击。

事件发生后,除了各大媒体跟踪报导外,民众也表达了自己的态度和立场。

事件当晚,成千上万的人在巴黎共和广场聚会,点燃蜡烛,悼念死难者,举着“Je suis Charlie”(我是查理)字样的条幅,力挺对言论自由的支持。

这个场景也同时出现在法国几乎所有的城市,各地几十万人在冬夜里或静默哀悼、流泪,或高唱马赛曲以抒发心绪。在10号,更有多达70万人参加了集会游行。

就连当初起诉《查理周刊》刊登讽刺伊斯兰教创始人穆罕默德漫画的法国伊斯兰协会负责人,也在电视台上宣称“我是查理”。

除了在几年前发表漫画讽刺穆罕默德,《查理周刊》最近两周还发表了有关伊斯兰国领袖巴格达迪(Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi)的漫画,内容是右手举起食指称新年要注意身体健康。这些内容,被认为是杂志社遭受袭击的原因。

自由撰稿人朱欣欣认为,《查理周刊》没有超出言论自由的边界,不属于对种族和信仰的歧视。

自由撰稿人朱欣欣:“彼此之间肯定有一些差异,那应当是在和平、非暴力的基础之上进行交流,而不能用武器的批判替代批判的武器,不能用靠暴力来扼杀对方表达的自由。”

笔名“变态辣椒”的漫画家王立铭,因为讽刺中国时政遭到全面封杀,他为了躲避中共抓捕,在去年10月流亡日本。

王立铭表示,穆斯林的极端主义分子和共产党都属于极权,都不能容忍人们对他们的讽刺和批判。

时政漫画家王立铭:“那实质上他们很像的。尤其是共产党在在五六十年代的时候,那和现在的状况是差不多的,画这样的人可能要判死刑的。”

目前中共官方展示出来的,对这场袭击的态度,与西方有很大的不同。

8号晚,近百名驻北京的外国记者,聚集在北京的三里屯想声援法国,但受到了中共警方干预。

官媒《环球时报》9号还发表题为《怒斥恐怖主义不等于挺争议漫画》的社评。文章说:西方不断因为漫画或文艺作品与伊斯兰世界产生摩擦,后者的受伤害感是真实的。即使西方认为自己的新闻自由没错,照顾对方的感受也比无视对方的感受更值得宣导。

中国民主党创始人查建国认为,巴黎的恐怖袭击事件的核心就是言论自由问题。而《环球时报》一直站在强权者的立场上,输出中共的价值观,为他们的控制言论自由做辩护。

中国民主党创始人查建国:“作为《环球时报》来说,它本身所代表的一个价值观里头一个核心的东西,就是专制的思想,就是限制言论自由的思想。所以它对于全世界力挺《查理周刊》、言论自由,他们是不接受的、反感的、反对的。”

查建国指出,对恐怖份子要治本,不光是要进行军事打击,还要针对他们那种与人类普世价值相反的,残暴、偏激、专制的价值观,进行批判。

其实,受攻击的《查理周刊》,不是一个只针对穆斯林的幽默讽刺画报,这份杂志既讽刺女权主义,还讽刺包括法国总统等各种社会、政治、文化,以及宗教现象。

采访/田净 编辑/宋风 后制/舒灿

CCP Holds Different Standpoints from Western Countries
Regarding Terrorism Attack on Charlie Hebdo

On Jan 7, when people are still in the good spirits of Christmas
and the New Year,
an unexpected terrorist attack broke French people’s hearts.

Charlie Hebdo, a famous French satirical weekly newspaper,
was attacked by Islamic terrorists, causing the deaths of 12 people.
It has triggered a shock in France like “911″ in the U.S.

Yet the CCP standpoint on this event is quite different from
that of western countries.

In the attack and following sieges, 17 people lost their lives
including 3 policemen. More than 20 people were injured.
3 terror suspects were shot to death.
It’s the most severe attack France has suffered in 50 years.

In a televised address, French President Francois Hollande ,
called on French people to unite to defend the values of
democracy, freedom and pluralism.

He emphasized that people would never give in to extremists.

Hollande also announced that flags will be flown at half-mast
for three days.

Leaders from the U.S., Britain, Germany and other countries
also condemned the attack.

Following it, people from all over the world also expressed
their attitude and standpoints regarding the event,
in addition to the media’s tracking reports.

The night of the attack, thousands of people gathered at
the Place de la Republique. They lit candles and held signs
that read “Je suis Charlie", meaning “I am Charlie",
expressing solidarity and support for freedom of speech.

The same thing took place in almost all cities in France.
Tens of thousands of people stood silent or sang La Marseillaise
to express solidarity against terrorism and pay homage
to the victims.
On Jan 10, as many as 700,000 people walked onto streets
and joined a rally.

The person in charge of the French Islamic Association
who also declared “Je suis Charlie",
once sued “Charlie Hebdo" for satirizing the founder of Islam,
Muhammad.

In addition to the published cartoon satirizing Muhammad,
“Charlie Hebdo" in recent two weeks published a cartoon image
of the Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.

The al-Baghdadi is depicted as saying:
“And especially good health."
There’s been speculation on whether the attack was related
in some way to the image.

Zhu Xinxin, freelance writer, said that “Charlie Hebdo"
hadn’t overstepped the boundaries of free speech.
It hadn’t committed any racial or religious discrimination.

Zhu Xinxin: “There might be some discrepancies,
which should have been addressed in a peaceful, non-violent way.
Physical weapons shouldn’t be used to punish
the weapon of expressing criticism.
Violence shouldn’t be used to kill freedom of speech."

Wang Liming, with pen name “abnormal pepper",
fled to Japan to escape from the CCP’s man-hunt in October 2014
because of his satirizing China’s political situation.

Wang Liming stated that both Islamic extremists and
the communist party belong to fundamentalism.
They can’t allow people to criticize or satirize them.

Wang: “They have a lot in common in essence.
Especially, in the CPP’s governance in the 1950s and 60s,
if anyone depicted a similar cartoon image,
he would have been sentenced to death.
It’s the same as happened to ‘Charlie Hebdo’."

Recently, the CCP showed different standpoints to the terrorist
attack from western countries.

On Jan 8, hundreds of foreign journalists gathered
at Sanlitun, Beijing, and supported France,
but they were interrupted by the CCP police.

The state-run media “the Global Times" published an article
titled “Denouncing Terrorism Doesn’t Mean
Supporting Controversial Cartoons".

The article said that frictions arise between western countries
and Islam because of cartoons or literary works.
It is real that Islamic feeling has been hurt.

Even though westerners think their journalistic freedom
is correct, care for Islamic feelings is worth more than
ignorance of their feelings.

Cha Jianguo, founder of China’s Democratic Party, said that
the core of the terrorist attack on “Charlie Hebdo"
is freedom of speech.

“The Global Times" always supports and speaks for the CCP,
and defends the party for its tight control of free speech.

Cha Jianguo: “The core value of the Global Times is
the ideology of dictatorship and suppression of free speech.
Therefore, when the whole world supports ‘Charlie Hebdo’
and freedom of speech, the Global Times can’t accept it
and even turns against it."

Cha also points out that in order to fundamentally
eliminate terrorists, military strikes aren’t enough.
Their values of violence, extremism
and despotism should also be repudiated.

Actually, “Charlie Hebdo" doesn’t only work on cartoons
satirizing Islam. It also satirizes all kinds of phenomena in
politics, society, culture and religion,
including feminism and even the French president.

Interview/TianJing Edit/SongFeng Post-Production/ShuCan

相关文章
评论